Title: Uncovering Hidden Gems: The Potential Impact of Underrated 2025-26 MLB Free Agents
As the baseball world eagerly anticipates the decisions of top players like Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette, there is a group of underrated free agents quietly waiting for their chance to shine in the upcoming 2026 season.
What exactly makes a free agent underrated? According to a recent analysis by B/R’s Joel Reuter, any player who remains unsigned and did not make the top 25 big board is considered for this distinction. These players may not have been on the radar initially, but they could offer significant value to teams if given the opportunity.
Let’s take a closer look at some of these hidden gems who have the potential to make a big impact:
1. Nick Madrigal (IF):
Often compared to Luis Arraez, Madrigal is known for his exceptional contact hitting. Despite setbacks due to injuries, he remains a versatile player at just 28 years old, making him a valuable asset as a backup.
2. Jordan Montgomery (LHP):
Coming off Tommy John surgery, Montgomery’s return in the second half of the season could be a game-changer for any team in need of pitching depth. If he can replicate his pre-injury form, he has the potential to provide significant contributions like Shane Bieber did in the past.
3. Michael Toglia (1B/RF):
A former first-round pick, Toglia has shown flashes of brilliance with his power hitting. Despite a rough 2025 season, his performance in the minor leagues suggests he has the tools to succeed at the major league level, making him a worthy consideration for teams with uncertainties in the first base position.
4. José Urquidy (RHP):
Injuries have plagued Urquidy in recent years, but there is hope that he can bounce back and regain his previous form. With a solid track record and still relatively young at 30, he presents a low-risk, high-reward opportunity for teams looking to bolster their pitching rotation.
These underrated free agents may not be household names, but their potential impact could be significant if given the chance to showcase their skills in the upcoming season. Teams in search of hidden talent and value signings should keep a close eye on these players as they could be the missing pieces to a successful campaign in 2026.
MLB: SEP 13 Cardinals at BrewersArizona Diamondbacks v San Diego PadresSeattle Mariners v Atlanta Braves
