Title: Examining MLB Teams’ Most Impactful Free-Agent Signings in History
The past few MLB offseasons have seen some eye-popping free-agent contracts, with players like Shohei Ohtani and Juan Soto landing record-breaking deals. While this winter may not bring such astronomical figures, one recent signing has already made waves.
Dylan Cease’s monumental seven-year, $210 million deal with the Blue Jays marks the largest free-agent acquisition in the team’s history. This significant move prompts us to delve into each team’s most expensive free-agent signing, evaluating their impact on the team and the player’s performance.
We’ve curated a list showcasing each team’s costliest free-agent signing based on the total value of the contract, assigning grades based on the player’s productivity, contribution to team success, and any potential trades that influenced the deal.
For the purpose of this analysis, we’ve excluded contract extensions and re-signings with previous teams to focus solely on external acquisitions. Therefore, notable names like Chris Davis, Alex Gordon, and Carlos Correa will not be featured, despite signing lucrative deals with their respective clubs.
Let’s take a closer look at some standout signings across the league:
Baltimore Orioles: SS Miguel Tejada (2004)
Contract: 6 years, $72 million
After an impressive stint in Oakland, Tejada’s arrival in Baltimore sparked immediate success. The former AL MVP’s stellar performance, including an AL-leading 150 RBI in his debut season, solidified his impact. His eventual trade to the Astros after four productive years marked the end of an era for the Orioles.
Grade: B
Boston Red Sox: LHP David Price (2016)
Contract: 7 years, $217 million
Price’s signing set a milestone as the largest pitcher contract at the time. While his tenure in Boston had its ups and downs, his pivotal role in the 2018 World Series triumph highlighted his value. Key playoff performances cemented his legacy, culminating in a title win before being part of a blockbuster trade to the Dodgers.
Grade: B
New York Yankees: RHP Gerrit Cole (2020)
Contract: 9 years, $324 million
Cole’s impact with the Yankees has been significant, with impressive stats and a well-deserved Cy Young award. However, recent injury setbacks have raised concerns about his future availability. A Tommy John surgery sidelined him for the entire 2025 season, casting uncertainty over his return for the upcoming season.
By dissecting these high-profile signings, we gain valuable insights into the dynamics of free-agent acquisitions and their lasting implications for both teams and players. As we await the next big moves in the baseball world, these historical signings serve as benchmarks for success and cautionary tales in the realm of free agency.
MLB: SEP 27 Mets at MarlinsPress conference for newly acquired pitcher Max ScherzerMLB: SEP 27 Mets at Marlins
